Letter to the Editor: Save the Alewife Brook makes case for CSO fix

July 28, 2026

Editor’s Note: This letter was written to the Select Board and other town boards, commissions and officials by the Save the Alewife Brook group in advance of the MWRA presentation to the Select Board about the combined sewer overflows (CSO). It has been edited.The Select Board heard from the MWRA and representatives of the Save the Alewife Brook organization about the potential plans to address the discharge of sewage into the Alewife Brook following storms.

To the Editor:

Massachusetts Water Resources Authority, together with the cities of Cambridge and Somerville, have a new plan to address sewage pollution that will continue to use Alewife Brook as an open sewer. The plan fails to address the health impacts on people who live near Alewife Brook, who use the Alewife DCR parkland, and use the nearby path to get to the Alewife T station.

The new plan does not acknowledge sewage flooding of Alewife Brook, and it does not end sewage pollution in Alewife Brook. It doesn’t even come close. Often when it rains, raw sewage is dumped into Alewife Brook, a flood-prone brook that runs through public state parkland, next to the popular Alewife Greenway path, and very close to people’s homes.

As you know, twice this week raw sewage was dumped into the brook. This is a densely populated area. The brook floods regularly and there is sewage in the floodwater. 5,000 people live in the Alewife Brook’s 100-year floodplain in the area’s most diverse and vulnerable Environmental Justice neighborhoods. At Alewife Brook, people have gotten sick from exposure to sewage floodwater.

Public Health Impacts Ignored

All of the sewage that is dumped into Alewife Brook is untreated: live e. coli, viruses, and parasites, including norovirus and intestinal worms. When CSOs discharge into the brook e. coli counts in the brook run a thousand times what the Environmental Protection Agency considers safe. Alewife sewage flooding has made people sick. There are documented cases of severe gastrointestinal illness after exposure to contaminated floodwaters, and a Boston University School of Public Health study links sewage overflows to spikes in emergency room visits due to gastrointestinal illness.

A more recent draft study found a link between aerosolized CSO particulates and gastrointestinal disease. Just living near CSO outfalls or walking past them can cause health problems severe enough to send you to the emergency room, especially for people with weakened immune systems, like infants, elderly folks, and cancer patients.

The brook flooded five times in 2023. Children, joggers, and parents pushing baby strollers went through sewage floodwater on state parkland. Sewage flooded a homeless encampment feet away from the Alewife T parking garage and the worst sewage outfall in the entire MWRA system.

The new sewage plan ensures many more decades of raw sewage in the brook. Under the plan, in a single 5-year storm, Cambridge and Somerville will dump 15 million gallons of raw sewageinto the brook, after $340 million is spent.

New Sewage Plan Does Not Acknowledge Sewage Flooding

Why does the plan fail? The planners have not looked at sewage flooding- the conveyance of CSO effluent to land areas bordering the Alewife Brook. Over 1000 pages in the plan report, over the course of four years and dozens of meetings, the alternatives analysis used by the planners does not evaluate raw sewage flooding. The plan looks at flooding and it looks at sewage. But it does not acknowledge sewage flooding at Alewife Brook or the associated public health impacts.

No to Grey Infrastructure on State Parkland

The plan’s strategy for Alewife Brook is only 0.1% sewer separation and 99.9% grey storage tanks, including a mile-long sewage storage tunnel under public parkland. Storage doesn’t end sewage pollution; it postpones it and only reduces the amount dumped into the Brook in isolated one-year storm events. Due to climate change and its larger storm events, the result of this plan is no improvement at Alewife Brook. MWRA’s plan is the “kicking the can down the road” approach.

Yes to Green Infrastructure on State Parkland

And to be clear about the parkland: we say YES to Green Stormwater Infrastructure on state parkland, constructed wetlands like the 3.4-acre Alewife Wetland, which cleans stormwater from 211 acres while reducing floods and sheltering wildlife. Twelve more acres of DCR parkland are available for three more wetlands. Green stormwater infrastructure is a public park enhancement. But a giant concrete sewage tank or tunnel is not a park improvement.Grey infrastructure belongs under streets and under redevelopment sites like the Alewife T garage, not on the public’s beloved parkland.

The CSO storage tanks and tunnel are undersized even for 2-year storms. And when storage fills up, 100% of additional sewage goes into the brook. This could happen even with smaller back-to-back storms. Tanks and tunnels can’t be expanded later at a reasonable cost, while climate change pushes sewage volumes two- to four-times higher by 2050. The old combined sewer system still used by Cambridge and Somerville was built for yesterday’s storms, not tomorrow’s. The solution is upgrading the combined sewer system with sewer separation.

Yes to Sewer Separation and Green Stormwater Infrastructure

Sewer separation is the best solution because it removes stormwater from the sewer system. Sewer separation means increased capacity in the local sewer system and the regional system. It means fewer sanitary sewer overflows and fewer combined sewer overflows. It means less flooding. It means fewer sewage backups into basements. It’s a win-win-win-win-win. Sewer separation is the climate-resilient solution, because unlike a concrete tank, it is an approach that scales with climate change as storms get bigger.

Cambridge has done sewer separation in the Huron/Concord neighborhood and that project gave us the Alewife Stormwater Wetland, with its thriving ecosystems which increase community wellbeing. Cambridge is half way done with sewer separation at Alewife Brook. Finish the job!

The solution in Cambridge is sewer separation plus green stormwater infrastructure and a properly sized tank at the Alewife MBTA station – not undersized tunnels on public parkland and 99.9% storage. And in Somerville, the solution is sewer separation, green stormwater infrastructure, and redirecting of CSO flows to an existing CSO treatment facility.

Save the Alewife Brook asks that you provide a written public comment, rejecting the plan of MWRA, Cambridge, and Somerville and asking for an end to sewage pollution at Alewife Brook through sewer separation and green stormwater infrastructure.

Kristin Anderson, Michael Lonetto, George Laite, David White, David Stoff, Eppa Rixey, Eugene Benson

Save the Alewife Brook

www.savethealewifebrook.org

Events

Free newsletter

Weather

Obituaries

Please Support Our Generous Sponsors

Judy Weinbger Leading Edge Real Estate logoIntelligent Labor and Moving logoArts Arlington logo
Go toTop

Don't Miss