letters
Letter logo

In praise of hands-on learning at AHS

July 23, 2023

Linda M. Clark of Arlington submitted the following letter to the editor:

What a joy it was to read of the “maker space” at AHS! And to see AHS has definitely put “A” into its “STEAM” curriculum. Read the story here >>

A few years back I read a book by Matthew B. Crawford called Shop Class as Soul Craft: An Inquiry into the Value of Work. As Harvey Mansfield of Harvard University said, “A superb combination of testimony and reflection … you can’t put it down.” I’ll attest to that.

By work, Crawford was emphasizing working with one’s hands; he deplored the elimination of shop classes in the majority of our high schools over the decades and linked that with the common misassumption that to work with one’s hands didn’t require much thinking. It implied that it was for those who didn’t have the intellectual ability to do academic work which primarily focuses on reading and writing.

He went on to say that too many students we call “underachievers” are often kids who are not motivated to sit and read and write as the only approach to learning. Give them a chance to do hands-on problem solving, whether it be in a woodworking or other “shops” calling for this and they become achievers. And are often then properly motivated to do some of the “academic work” to improve and expand on their skills.

Google “kids and hands-on learning” and see the myriad articles attesting to its benefits for all students and of all ages, too. Sad to see that while we generally agree that hands-on learning is essential for young learners, somehow we have forgotten that this applies to older kids as well.

Tied to this underappreciation for hands-on learning is the lack of crafts and trades people for the construction industry today. Very good and profitable career opportunities lie ahead for those kids who graduate from high school with this exposure to hands-on learning.

While a college education is a value for many, IMHO it has been oversold as the only way to success. Kudos to AHS for making the experience of working with one’s hands available to its students and giving them the chance to see the value and satisfaction that it gives them — and for truly integrating A for Art into its STEAM approach as well.

I cannot close without kudos, too, for that terrific teacher, Nate Muehleisen. He epitomizes the best of the teaching profession. I hope someone in the administration has the sense to nominate him for “MA Teacher of the Year.”


This letter was published Sunday, July 23, 2023.

Bob Sprague

You can see Bob Sprague's resume at www.yourarlington.com/participate/17/2396-resume-bob-sprague

Events

Free newsletter

Weather

Obituaries

Please Support Our Generous Sponsors

Judy Weinbger Leading Edge Real Estate logoIntelligent Labor and Moving logoArts Arlington logo
Go toTop

Don't Miss