Race and police reform logo

Part 5: History of police unions: Time to change

September 30, 2020

Barbara Thornton, a Precinct 16 Town Meeting member and former Capital Planning Committee member for 30-plus years, has written the fifth in a series calling for dialogue around police reform and racial justice in Arlington. Contact arlingtonma.voices at gmail.com.

By the late 1960s, the new ideal of “professionalism” built on the historic quasi-military tradition of policing. Police were seeing their wages decline relative to other jobs in the economy. They saw other Civil Service jobs unionize to increase pay and working conditions.

Lawmakers, municipal managers and police chiefs nationwide fought the attempts by local “rank-and-file” police to organize unions. Members of the military were not allowed to unionize. Police, with a quasi-military role, should not either. Instead, local police began to organize as “benevolent associations”, a precursor to today’s police unions.

Union impact

During the 1970s many cities, including Boston, signed agreements making work conditions, as well as police department policies, negotiable with police unions. This abrogation of municipalities’ managerial prerogatives opened the door to weaken municipal control over police behavior.  City officials paid more attention to the immediate goal of budget management and ceded their control, accountability and right to discipline bad police behavior.  This imbalance in negotiation happens when an employee has a career job expectation of 35 years in the and the municipal side is an elected official with a job expectation of maybe eight years.  Municipal officials across the USA “let the horse out of the barn” by short term thinking and inadequate negotiating skills.

Police benevolent associations “rode that horse” to develop strong police unions, building on their effective negotiation strategies against their locally elected officials to build a stronger power base with elected officials at all levels. Police unions have become more adept at rewarding elected officials with contributions and intimidating them with political opposition. 

For decades, municipal officials complained they cannot remove the “bad apples” in a police department because they would lose the legal battle with the union. Over time, this has become true. If a municipality attempts to discipline a police officer, the union becomes involved. The case is referred to arbitration. The companies in the arbitration-industry depend on referrals. Police unions have the upper hand in picking an arbitrator. That gives the arbitrator an incentive to find on behalf of the police over the interests of the individual municipal government, which lacks the statewide organizational strength to benefit the arbitrator’s future business.

Adept at defending members

Police unions have become adept in fighting for their membership, in donating to elected officials and in manipulating the arbitration process. They also have consolidated political strength by implicit and explicit threats against elected public officials.  Last November, a City Council member in Santa Ana, Calif., was forced out of office on a “recall petition” initiated by the local police union in response to the city councilor’s effort to cut the police department budget by $25 million. This is in a city where the police budget is already about 45 percent of the total city budget. The campaign was led by the union’s professional staff, who are not members of any police department. Unions are a separate organization from the police officers they serve. The police union was successful in eliminating this opposition, and in intimidating other elected officials that may not agree with the union’s wishes.

Police unions have also become adept at manipulating the public’s understanding of the police function in society. Police are portrayed as risking their lives and being the “thin blue line” between chaos and safety. In fact, studies show that less than 5 percent of the service calls to police are related to violent crime.

In each of the last five years, police in the U.S. have killed about 1000 people per year. During the same period, about 100 police officers nationwide were killed in the line of duty. There is a huge imbalance here. We mourn the police officers who have died in the line of duty. We mourn the citizens who have been wrongly killed by police officers. We must acknowledge both. Police unions do their membership no favors by attempting to distort this truth.Police do suffer from a disproportionate amount of stress. It is not easy to go out on a job with a gun on your hip in the most heavily armed country in the world. White male police officers in Buffalo, N.Y., for example, have a life expectancy 22 years shorter than the average American male.

The people of Arlington do not want their police officers to feel unappreciated. They want to see these officers acknowledge that bad behavior happens and there is a need to reexamine what police do. This needs to be a conversation between police and the people they serve. Our police officers need to step out from behind the police unions, now sowing dissonance and misinformation, and talk honestly with the community about how to rebuild this relationship.

 


Sept. 23, 2020: Part 4: Building a coalition for change


This viewpoint was published Wednesday, Sept. 30, 2020. 

Do you have a comment about this series, which you want the public to read? Copy and paste it in the Comment window below. Be sure to include your full name.

Bob Sprague

You can see Bob Sprague's resume at www.yourarlington.com/participate/17/2396-resume-bob-sprague

Events

Free newsletter

Weather

Obituaries

Please Support Our Generous Sponsors

Judy Weinbger Leading Edge Real Estate logoIntelligent Labor and Moving logoArts Arlington logo
Go toTop

Don't Miss