School Committee logo
School Committee logo

Further discussion of 8:30 a.m. start time for AHS, middle schools due

March 10, 2019

5-2 vote shows differences about delaying change

UPDATED, March 10: The issue of later start times for the middle and high schools dominated the Feb. 28 School Committee meeting, as members weighed in on whether this change, which research shows improves student learning and health, will be put in place by next September.

While parents and teachers surveyed have previously supported the later start time, Superintendent Kathleen Bodie said issues with this plan remain. Some School Committee members wanted to move forward, and a 5-2 vote placed the matter for further discussion on the March 14 agenda.


March 10, 2019: Factual opinion from Susse includes survey data on start time, calendar


In 2014, the American Academy of Pediatrics recommended middle and high schools delay the start time of school to 8:30 a.m. or later. In its technical report, the academy reviewed the scientific evidence establishing a different sleep cycle for adolescents. According to the results, the biologically determined sleep cycle makes it difficult for teenagers to receive the required 8.5 to 9.5 hours of sleep if they need to be at school before 8:30.

The scientific studies cited by the academy show that the consequences of chronic sleep deprivation related to early start times are “compelling” and quantifiable: more tardiness, more attention/concentration difficulties, lower academic performance, more absences because of mental health issues and more automobile accidents.

While after-school sports schedules have acted as an impediment to changing to an earlier start time, Bodie reported that 50 percent of the schools in the Middlesex Athletic League now open their schools at 8:30.

Bodie cites’deeper issues’ 

While Bodie reported, based on last fall’s survey, there was “positive sentiment, in general, for a late start,” she concluded “Looking at it more deeply, issues have arisen [and] that these issues needed to be addressed.”

Among the issues that needed to be addressed, Bodie enumerated the following: contractual issues, more time to plan, more time to discuss, logistics of scheduling and possibly the rebuild of the high school, but at the moment she had “no idea” yet how it might be an issue.

Bodie advised the committee that while “it is good to have the sentiment of the committee, there are next steps” and recommended “more planning steps before we make a decision.” While visiting the two middle schools and the high school this year, she reported that the faculty and staff would find a 2019 change in start time stressful because of child-care arrangements and traffic.

The superintendent concluded: “My recommendation at this point is I have come to understand from a lot of discussions that have gone on is that more things need to be worked on.”

Committee responds

Committee member Jennifer Susse whole-heartedly supported the start time moved to 8:30 beginning next September. She said she made that decision because “it is the best thing we can do for academic achievement and social-emotional health of our students.”

Reporting about the survey on the start, which she conducted as chair of the community-relations subcommittee, she said that 73 percent of parents favored a later start time, while 12 percent were unsure. A majority of teachers also favored a later start time but not as strongly as the parents.

Committee member Len Kardon introduced a motion to move the start time to 8:30 next September for both middle schools and the high school. He said that moving the start time and any possible road blocks were discussed three years ago. The next year, the teachers and staff contracts stated that the School Committee was in charge of the start time, with notification to everyone in advance.

Now, he continued, all the issues, such as traffic, are coming up again. He recognized this change is not easy for everyone. Still, he urged the committee to get on with this change for the good of Arlington’s students.

Committee member Jane Morgan responded: “Nothing gets things done like having a deadline.” She expressed her support for the change in 2019, reminding everyone that it hasn’t happened in the last three years.

Motion on first read, voted due

Committee member Paul Schlichtman inquired whether the motion would be considered a first read. When answered in the affirmative, he announced he would support it, because if there were objections, they could be considered at the next meeting.

Committee member Jeff Thielman had a different response. He suggested that the plan to change the start time should emanate from the school administration. He said “boards work best when responding to a clear plan from the administration.”

Thielman asked that all three principals of the secondary schools attend the next meeting of the School Committee to share their thoughts on the start time. He anticipated there will be “a lot of other people in the room” at this meeting. The next scheduled meeting is 6:30 p.m. Thursday, March 14.

Morgan responded, “I don’t have great expectations about what planning is going to come in two weeks, since there is no incentive to do this, and the desire of the superintendent and principals are to not do this.”

Kardon agreed with Morgan, citing delays for the last three years. He said he expected a plan from the administration a long time ago.

Member Bill Hayner asked that the plan be circulated in advance of the meeting.

Bodie stated that it was unrealistic to have a plan in two weeks. The issues that came up were unknown at the time and are still being discussed. Assistant Principal Roderick MacNeal Jr. also said it would be difficult to design a plan, because he ”has other things to do over the next two weeks.”

Chair Kirsi Allison-Ampe took her turn and said she was voting against the motion. She offered two reasons: First, she looked over the literature and found the gains in academic performance from changing start times was greater when they were changed from 7 to 8:30. When changed from 8 to 8:30 there were still significant gains but not as dramatic. Second, she saw deadline on a vote as a “hammer,” as it forces a decision.

The committee proceeded to vote on Kardon’s motion as a first read. It passed 5 yes, 2, no, no abstentions. Kardon, Susse, Hayner, Morgan and Schlichtman voted in the affirmative; Thielman and Allison-Ampe voted in the negative.

The motion will be on the agenda on for a final vote March 14. 


Jan. 14, 2019: 8:30 a.m. start time weighed


This news summary by YourArlington freelancer Jo Anne Preston was published Wednesday, March 6, 2019, and updated March 10, to add a link.

Bob Sprague

Find out about the founder here >>

Events

Free newsletter

Weather

Obituaries

Please Support Our Generous Sponsors

Judy Weinbger Leading Edge Real Estate logoIntelligent Labor and Moving logoArts Arlington logo
Go toTop