Expressing the following viewpoint about the Mass. Ave. Corridor Phase II project is Gina Sonder of Arlington. This is a Sept. 28 letter to Laura Castelli, project manager, transportation systems – planning and operations, for VHB, the town’s consultant. It is republished with the author’s permission.
I was in attendance for the Sept. 22 presentation at Town Hall and spoke with you briefly afterwards. Overall, I was pleased with the proposed improvements to this area, but as a resident, have some observations from a user’s point of view. I wanted to be able to send you my comments in writing and go into a little more detail, so that the team might consider these points as the project moves forward.
Not a city or new suburb
Arlington is a suburban historic New England town, not a city or a new suburb. The character of Arlington with its tree-lined avenues is both part of its New England character and its attraction to residents and visitors. Pedestrian friendly public ways do not necessarily mean lots of planters1 and benches and other “street furniture,” but rather a pleasant, walkable, experience. I think that the attention paid to the motorists and the cyclists in these concept plans is admirable, but the pedestrians and the mass-transit commuters have been given too little thought in comparison.
Let’s start with the Civic Center Concept Plan and “walk” east. All of the street trees on the south side of the avenue have been eliminated, and the sidewalk is shown to be 8 feet wide. I fully understand that the four lanes of traffic and the two cycle lanes and the parking are all maintained, here, but this is our most historic block in Arlington, and these concept plans rely on the trees behind the walls of the Town Hall and Town Garden to compensate for the absence of street trees. As admitted during the presentation, the drawing shows many more trees behind the stone wall than are actually present.
The town has lost some trees to the drought this summer. Hotter summers are our future, and shade trees make a huge difference in quality of life and comfort. The Civic Center’s sidewalk has been pulled back about 4 feet – this is where sign-holders are allowed to gather to promote their candidates during elections. Is there any way to gain back enough space to restore the tree lined public way? This stretch of sidewalk is our Central Park.
A recommendation at the Town Hall crosswalk – make the bump-out opposite Town Hall a generous drop-off area, and center a nice wide crosswalk on the Town Hall entrance. I attended the September meeting because I could have been badly injured while crossing Mass. Ave. from the library at Spengler Way/Water Street, and was pleased to see that the crosswalk has been studied and could be moved westward, away from the curve in the avenue (therefore, more visible to westbound traffic) to land squarely on the South side of the avenue, with beacons installed to alert drivers that pedestrians are in the crosswalk. I trust that the crosswalk surface will be uniform, unlike the current location which contains manhole covers and uneven trip hazards, installed with more permanent marking than the existing seasonally worn paint.
Share some sidewalk with south side
In that same stretch of Mass. Ave., from Water Street/Spengler Way to Route 60, VHB has increased the sidewalk width on the North side of the avenue focusing on this as the “Commercial Block.” I would like to suggest that a minimum two feet (2’) of that increase be given to the South side, which is already very narrow, and not easily passable either when people are waiting for the bus or when pedestrians are walking in opposite directions from Spengler Way until the walk widens at the entry to First Parish. The current light poles, street signs, and new benches further obstruct passage.
Even the crosswalk at the driveway to the Robbins does not squarely land on the eastern corner near the bus stop – which serves three bus lines. Pedestrian flow on this South side of the avenue should not be sacrificed for outdoor café seating and other optional amenities for property owners on the facing side.
Now we come to the Great Intersection – which is not part of this project’s scope – although the MASSACHUSETTS AVENUE PHASE II PROJECT EXTENTS plan indicates that it is; so, where is the line defining where the “Safe” project ends and this project begins? I ask this because the bicycle lane treatment on the two corners differs; and I worry about the cyclists going straight westbound, where the cycle lane is at the curb and there is no “bike box.” If this project scope does get to re-evaluate the “Safe” design, I am quite certain that the sidewalk space on the northwest corner and the crossing patterns will need a second look.
Another look at Whittemore
Whittemore Park is another historic landmark in Arlington Center, and visibility of the Jefferson Cutter House may be an issue but think of Harvard Yard, where the trees are tall and the canopies are high, allowing views through the Yard. Cutting down mature trees and replacing some with younger specimens seems shortsighted. The greater issue is permeability from Mass. Ave. into the space, and inviting people into the sanctuary. Instead of taking down all the fencing, I would suggest creating a path with seating just inside the fencing – easily visible from the sidewalk, inviting people to come inside to sit down or stroll. This plan takes away the peacefulness of the park and makes it an outward facing green-space.
It is unrealistic to plan for a farmers market in this space, however it would be a welcome program space for craft festivals, entertainment and civic activities. Farmers’ market stalls need to be adjacent to their trucks for access throughout market hours, and although there is a brick ramp (once a street) to the area; supporting that weekly traffic would not be practical for such heavy use and the space is not adequate for the current vendors.
If the granite posts and fencing are completely removed from the park and the old tracks become walkway, the most likely users of this nice smooth shortcut will be cyclists, no? It makes me sad to think that none of the track would be preserved because a boy tripped and fell, but the character of the space will change, and maybe that’s just what the town wants.
Lastly, I wish to address the Broadway Plaza area as a pedestrian, bus commuter and resident. I had not expected to weigh in on this part of the project, but have included some drawings here to better show you my thoughts.
Broadway Plaza – Citizen Proposal Scheme 1
Broadway Plaza – Citizen Proposal Scheme 1A (alternate traffic flow plan)
Within these drawings, I wish to make several points. I recognize that I do not know all the factors that went into the current concept plans, but please indulge me, here.
Further points to address
I. As a pedestrian, it is nice to have a continuous sidewalk, and even better if it is buffered from traffic and shaded from the hot sun. Your current plan addresses this point.
II. The current layover location for the #87 bus must be relocated in order to realize a plaza & park that can be enjoyed. Outdoor seating with idling bus fumes is not pleasant nor visually attractive. Depending on how the route for this service is addressed, various possibilities come to mind.
III. I propose that the westbound #87 turn on Franklin Street and enter the end of Broadway (one-way traffic) from Mass. Ave. This addresses several issues at once.
A. The congestion at Mass. Ave.
B. The bus turning across the median
C. The “cut-through” aspect of Alton Street traffic entering Mass Ave. is eliminated.
D. Broadway westbound traffic and plaza drop-off/parking traffic enter Mass. Ave. at a signaled intersection.
E. Bus stop is located closer to a signaled crosswalk (Scheme 1) and faces the direction for departure.
F. Bus stop is located on the main avenue, and a new crosswalk connects it to other mass-transit buses (Scheme 1A).
Crosswalks at Franklin
IV. The signaled intersection at Mass. Ave. and Franklin Street have two crosswalks in this proposal, both parallel to Franklin Street; the easterly one landing at continuous sidewalk and a bus stop, the westerly one relocated slightly farther west to clear a driveway and going to the fire station. The fire station perimeter does not provide continuous sidewalk. Commuters for Buses #77, #79, & #350 use the bus stop at the intersection of Avon Place and Mass. Ave. (eastbound) and near 395 Mass. Ave. (westbound). It would be optimal to have the #87 bus also have a Franklin Street stop on its route (Scheme 1) or the Mass. Ave. buses to stop in the same location as the proposed new #87 stop on Mass. Ave. and a new crosswalk added to connect the buses (Scheme 1A).
If the town wants to encourage commuters to cross at crosswalks
A. The bus stop needs to be located near the crosswalk or…
B. The crosswalk needs to be located near the bus stop.
V. Alton Street and Parking Lot use. Concern was raised over the potential rise in traffic at Alton Street. I believe that it is imperative that traffic flow into Broadway from Mass. Ave. and that there is no entry to Alton Street from Broadway, but that the cars which enter can flow smoothly in and out of the parking zone. For that reason, I would prefer a looped flow, if space permits (Scheme 1) than a closed lot with a single entry/exit; but if the design
configuration remains as presented, congestion at the entry/exit point should be minimized so as not to conflict with cars or buses entering or exiting the street.
Plaza parking
VI. Plaza Parking Lot. Drop-off Points should be incorporated into this area, as well as taxi/Uber spaces. Can deliveries be serviced through alleyways or must this also be considered?
VII. Broadway Plaza and Memorial Park. If this is a public town space, what arrangement is made with the town to have restaurant properties be allocated Café seating space?
VIII. Memorial Park. Can the service monuments act as a permeable wall to define the edge of the Park? A 4-foot stone wall seems alienating. The 2-foot separation wall does what – buffer the Park from the traffic? The Memorial Wall and 4-foot stone wall seem to block the view of and impede access to the
Civil War Monument. My proposals are quite undefined for this area since I do not know that content of the meetings between town groups, but I do believe that the Memorial should be more connected to the Plaza – now a problem – and visible to pedestrians and traffic along Mass. Ave.
These rough sketches and the text attempt to describe my ideas. If you would like further clarification, I would gladly meet with you to discuss these points further.
I hope that some of the points are useful as you move on to develop 25% design plans. I look forward to seeing the revised drawings.
1 The 6-foot-high, edged rectangular sidewalk planter boxes in East Arlington are a tripping hazard and a maintenance nightmare, as pointed out during the public discussion.
Sept. 25, 2016: Current Mass. Ave. ‘concept’ reshaping Center spurs praise, scrutiny
This viewpoint was published Monday, Oct. 3, 2016.
What do you think? Your comments are welcome below, in the window marked “Guest” (and you do not have to log in), but you must include your full name.




