Initial map needs more work; requested document received
The process that will change elementary school district borders, on the table for at least 11 years, has finally gotten underway, but what the proposed map looks like remains available only in a limited way.
At its first public meeting, on Tuesday, Nov. 15, the Redistricting Committee and 12 members of the audience saw the planned map in paper copies and projected on a screen in the School Committee Room, sixth floor, Arlington High School.
After about an hour and half of discussion, Superintendent Kathleen Bodie and Chief Information Officer David Good said the committee had much more work to do before a map is ready for the general public.
[On Thursday, Nov. 17, YourArlington made a public-records request for a publishable, color version of the map. By late that evening, it was received. The draft map was published Nov. 18.]
Guiding the redistricting effort will be this overall aim, Bodie said — trying to equalize class sizes.
The state School Building Authority, which has a clear role in the seven-school rebuilding effort, ongoing since 1998, calls for getting all schools to be close to design capacity as possible.
That “may or may not happen,” Bodie said, referring the charts on a handout. “There’s lots of unevenness.”
One chart showed 56 more students than the existing capacity for all seven schools. The ideal is three classes for each grade, she said.
She also said school design can have an impact: Dallin, which has the most students over, “doesn’t feel” crowded, because of the way the building is laid out.
“I’d like to get away from busing,” she added.
As for the long-delayed redistricting process, Bodie said it can be “very emotional,” because neighborhood schools, an Arlington tradition, fosters close relationships.
Trying to counter that, she said that, after the changes, students will see the same families at Ottoson, the middle-school leveler.
In thinking about the map, she asked the panel to consider a placing “buffer zone.” This would be on a school’s border; such a zone gives administrators some flexibility to make decisions about which school a new student should attend. She admitted it’s “hard to figure out.”
Advances in GS
Work to create a preliminary map has been made possible in part because of computer advances in geographic information systems. The town’s GIS coordinator, Adam Kurowski, presented a series of maps.
“It used to be pins on a map,” Bodie said. “Adam is an expert … he came along at the right time.”
One map showing current borders for the seven elementary schools were dotted 2,500 points, representing Arlington students.
Another illustrated the walking distance from each school, in one- and two-mile distances. GIS software drew the lines.
A third map showed routes to the schools with two, one or no sidewalks.
A fourth map showed traffic data along Arlington’s streets provided by the state Department of Transportation.
The aim is to produce a map, to be recommended to the School Committee next June, that would include all of this data.
It was clear, based on the discussion Nov. 15, that the preliminary overall map would need a lot of work.
One parent noted the sliver of a proposed Stratton district shown south of Mass. Ave. and pointed out that some students would have to cross two main thoroughfares — the avenue and Summer Street.
Another parent, Len Kardon, said he thought the Dallin numbers “misleading.”
He said the “design capacity” numbers used at the meeting are not the original building-design capacities. He said they were “adjusted” to take account of rooms used for special-education students (substantially separate classrooms) when at least at Dallin, the classrooms used for SPED purposes are actually not any of the 18 regular-ed classrooms in the original design.
So the design capacity at Dallin was 380. With 421 students, he said it is still over that design capacity but not nearly as much as when you use the adjusted capacity number of 336.
Starks suggested adding data about the impact of the housing projects at Mill Street and the former Symmes Hospital. She also asked for the inclusion of Metco data when illustrating the number of students.
Bodie asked committee members to discuss this at the School Council level, and she assigned some homework — to review what was discussed and return on 7 p.m. Tuesday, Dec. 13, to the School Committee Room.
The members of the committee are:
Supt. Kathleen Bodie
CFO Diane Johnson
Bishop School
Mark McAneny (Principal)
Dorothy Commons (Parent)
Brackett School
Stephanie Zerchykov (Principal)
Roly Chaput (Parent)
Dallin School
Tara Rossi (Principal)
Lauren Boyle (Parent)
Hardy School
Deborah D’Amico (Principal)
Ned Hall (Parent)
Peirce School
Karen Hartley (Principal)
Charlie Radoslovich (Parent)
Cate Oranchak (Parent) (alternate)
Stratton School /Thompson School
Sheryl Donovan (Principal – Stratton/Thompson)
and or Jackie Daley Stratton School Liaison
Chuck Hannon (Stratton School Parent)
Thompson parent rep: not yet appointed
School Committee rep: Leba Heigham
Adam Kurowski: GIS coordinator
A look back to 2000
On Nov. 15, Supeintendent Bodie called the redistricting effort “long overdue.” A look at School Committee minutes shows how long.
At its Sept. 12, 2000, meeting, member discussed a tour they had taken of the Bishop School, then newly rebuilt.
Committee member Michael Healy “had concerns that the Bishop is being used at capacity at this point with the science, art, and music and community rooms in use as classrooms. He questioned if this would be ongoing for the next 4-5 years as the remaining schools are being renovated and is this the wisest choice.
“He suggested that perhaps we should look into all of our resources for housing our students elsewhere. He has concerns on what the Stratton will look like after housing all of the students from other schools.”
Then Superintendent Kathleen Donovan “responded that the only alternative would be mobile classrooms, which are very expensive; she believes that the current system is working very well and that we will need the money for the four remaining schools.
“Mr. Healy stated that maybe we should revisit redistricting, start talking about what the district lines would look like and have a more definitive date on when it will begin ….
“[Donovan] stated that she would meet with Alan McClennen and Kevin O’Brien [of town planning] to look at the geographical makeup to see who is moving in where the children live.
“[Denis] Sullivan agreed with Mr. Healy that we do need to have a discussion on redistricting issues but he would also like to look at the global picture.”
This story was first published Wednesday, Nov. 16, 2011, and updated Nov. 17 and 18.




